Avocado Pie 2.0
Posted by Crystal B on 2008/07/02 @ 12:10 pm

Several months ago, while browsing the produce section of our local grocer, Chris and I ran into an old friend. We told him about our bakery and food blog, and immediately he tells us that we must make avocado pie. I'm sure we made some sort of face at the idea and moved along. Even for avocado lovers...an avocado pie sounds weird. The other day, I was thinking of something to make. Out of nowhere, I recall a voice saying "make avocado pie". I looked up all of the recipes for avocado pie (there's like a handful, none of them are vegan) and decided what my next move was going to be. This is a recipe that you'll love. It's veganized and tested, tweaked and carefully created to blow your taste buds right off of your tongue.

Let me talk about the flavor while my taste buds are still buzzing. This tastes a lot like kiwi, believe it or not. The texture is like a cheesecake, but it isn't one at all. It's light, refreshing and very smooth. Its flavor can be likened to avocado, lime juice, cream cheese, a small amount of sugar and sweetened condensed soy milk. Did I mention you don't even have to turn your oven on for this?

PIE INGREDIENTS

  • 1 Graham Cracker Crust (avoid premade, recipe below)
  • 2 Large Ripe Avocados (pitted, peeled and pureed)
  • 1/2 Cup Fresh Lime Juice
  • 1 Tablespoon Agar Powder
  • 5 Ounces sweetened condensed soy milk (see recipe below)
  • 1/3 Cup Vegan Cream Cheese
GRAHAM CRACKER CRUST INGREDIENTS
  • 20 Graham Crackers
  • 3/4 Cup Vegan Margerine (Do NOT melt.)
SWEETENED CONDENSED SOYMILK INGREDIENTS
  • 3/4 Cup Better Than Milk Soy Powder
  • 3/4 Cup Water
  • 6 Tablespoons Vegan Margerine
  • 1 1/2 Cups Sugar
  • 1/8 Teaspoon Salt

GRAHAM CRACKER CRUST DIRECTIONS

  1. Crumble graham crackers (food processor is the best for this).
  2. In a mixing bowl, use a fork or your fingers to mix margerine with graham cracker crumbs.
  3. In a pie dish/pan, use your hands to form a graham cracker crust.
  4. Set aside until pie filling is ready to be poured into your pie crust.
SWEETENED CONDENSED SOYMILK DIRECTIONS
  1. Mix water and soy milk powder.
  2. Boil or microwave on high for 1.5 minutes. Set aside.
  3. In a separate pan on the stove, melt margerine on MED-HI.
  4. Once it's melted, add sugar to melted margarine. Whisk immediately to incorporate. You don't need to worry about "cooking" the sugar. The texture should be fluffy and powdery.
  5. Immediately, add hot soymilk mixture and salt to the margerine/sugar mixture.
  6. Gently Boil for 5 minutes.
  7. Cool until ready to use (I usually stick mine in the freezer for a minute to cool quickly)
  8. The recipe makes much more than you need for the pie so expect to have extra.
PIE FILLING DIRECTIONS
  1. Puree avocado (I like to turn ON my food processor as I drop-in the avocado pieces, to avoid avocado chunks in the puree)
  2. While the food processor is still smoothing the avocados, add-in vegan cream cheese.
  3. Once they are completely combined, turn OFF the food processor.
  4. Juice your limes and bring the lime juice to a gentle boil on your stovetop.
  5. Once boiling, REMOVE from heat and ADD agar powder. QUICKLY whisk the agar into the lime juice.
  6. Once the thickened lime juice is a little cooler, turn ON your food processor again (it still has the avocado and cream cheese mixture in it) and add-in your thickened lime juice.
  7. Finally, get your cooled sweetened condensed soymilk and ADD (ONLY 5 OUNCES) to the food processor with the other ingredients.
  8. Once it's completely incorperated, turn OFF your food processor.
ASSEMBLY
  1. Pour avocado pie filling into graham cracker crust.
  2. Chill overnight.

It's yummy as is. If you're really treating yourself, add some chocolate sauce, vegan whipped cream, shaved chocolate and graham cracker crumbs. And, take a seat.

That pie is my favorite color! Thank you for providing the recipe--your cooking, baking, and photography skills are brilliant. I can't wait to make this, once finals are over...
Posted by Destiny on 2008/06/02 @ 11:15 am
this seriously blows my mind. i need to make it!
Posted by katie on 2008/06/02 @ 11:48 am
OMG I have to make this!! I love, love, love avocados so I'm sure I'll love this pie :)

It looked beautiful by the way!

P.S. Did you say you own a bakery?
Posted by Paulina on 2008/06/03 @ 12:42 pm
That looks AMAZING!!

Does the avocado brown at all? I am considering making this and bring it in to (omni, in the South!) work.

That looks SOOO good.
Posted by Pamela on 2008/06/03 @ 04:53 am
Paulina, yes! Alwaysbaked.net

Pamela,
I've had it for over 36 hours and it's the prettiest shade of pale green. No browning at all.
Posted by Crystal on 2008/06/03 @ 04:58 am
that's crazy! and you're a genius, and as soon as I find soy cream cheese in my neck of the woods, I'm subjecting people to mysterious green pies of deliciousness. :o
Posted by Liz² on 2008/06/03 @ 09:59 am
You are simply amazing. I'm going to wow everyone at my next potluck with this pie!! Perfect for summertime!!
Posted by Ashley Nicole on 2008/06/03 @ 03:52 am
Ok, enough reading about this and seeing the pics. We're family you just need to go ahead and make me something and send it my way!
Posted by Your Cousin - Melissa on 2008/06/04 @ 09:49 am
Oh my goodness! My mum is gonna LOVE this pie to BITS since she's an avocado fanatic!! Thanks so much for the recipe, you're so talented! I still can't believe everything you created is VEGAN!!!
Posted by Cecilia on 2008/06/05 @ 04:55 am
I hate to get all technical on you but what size pie pan did you use? And just regular size graham crackers? I live here in Austin so I'm hoping Whole Foods will have the soymilk powder. Thanks!
Posted by Marie on 2008/06/06 @ 06:52 am
The pan I used was a small 8" round pan. I used it, because I hate the flimsy foil/aluminum ones. My pan has sides that are perpendicular to the bottom of the pan, which is what I prefer for a solid pie. Use something you'd use for a vegan cheesecake.

I used regular vegan graham crackers. The one that has 4 pieces to a "sheet". When I say "20 Graham Crackers", I mean 20 of the "sheets".

I'm in Austin,too.The HEB on Oltorf and Congress has a Nature's Harvest section. In there, on the shelf is soymilk powder. Whole Foods will have it too. That HEB has everything for this pie including the tofutti sour cream and vegan graham crackers.
Posted by Crystal on 2008/06/06 @ 09:08 am
that looks really good! I've always thought that sweet and avocado wouldn't go together, but your endorsement makes me want to give it a try. Thanks for the recipe!
Posted by Michelle on 2008/06/07 @ 06:08 am
I am thrilled to have come upon this mouthwatering recipe. I have already forwarded it to my daughter. So cool! What whipcream do you use? Do you have a recipe? Off to the store to shop for avocados and limes. :o)
Posted by sheree on 2008/06/07 @ 01:56 am
Sheree, We had some soyatoo in our fridge from an earlier trip to Whole Foods. I don't know of any actual good recipes for vegan whip cream. Most that have tried will tell you the recipes using silken tofu and a blender taste gross. Until myself or someone gets that figured out, it's soyatoo for us. Tastes awesome,though.
Posted by Crystal on 2008/06/07 @ 04:34 am
I just made that for a barbeque tonight - I was going to make it last night, but we couldn't find the cream cheese in the store. Modifications - I added less of the condensed milk, arrowroot powder instead of corn starch, and stuck it in the freezer since it won't be chilling overnight. I'm pretty excited about it, though - I had enough left over for a small bowl, so that went in the fridge. I'll let you know how it turned out later!
Posted by Trish on 2008/06/14 @ 03:16 am
Wow! This looks and sounds delicious. This is a genius recipe. Thanks for sharing. I will have to give it a try.
Posted by Krys on 2008/07/02 @ 06:34 am
Another fantastic-looking recipe from you! Yeah!
Posted by JohnP on 2008/07/02 @ 06:37 am
Simply beautiful. Great job!
Posted by Jennifer on 2008/07/07 @ 04:35 am
Oh man, so intriguing, but I'm not an avocado lover, so I'm skeptical!
Posted by Melisser on 2008/07/11 @ 08:11 am
See....this is one of those moments when I wish I lived next door. This looks outstanding! I thought it was vegan key lime. But, I'm intrigued by the avocado idea!
Posted by Creature of Habit on 2008/07/16 @ 11:12 am
This looks and sounds amazing. And so creative! I love avocados with pretty much anything so why not in a pie?
Posted by Vegan_noodle on 2008/07/18 @ 03:10 am
mhmm this looks exactly like keylime pie- would've fooled me at a dessert table!
Posted by Joanna on 2008/10/07 @ 12:08 pm
aah, love this vegan version!! it is fantastic :)
Posted by ttfn300 on 2009/01/10 @ 08:51 am
This looks absolutely GORGEOUS. I love avocado. I love pie. PERFECT :)
Posted by marika @ madcap on 2009/04/06 @ 04:34 am